Defense Secretary Leon E. Panetta is lifting the military’s official ban on women in combat, which will open up hundreds of thousands of additional front-line jobs to them, senior defense officials said Wednesday.
“You accept, then, as we have described it, this partnership of the women with our men in the matter of education and children and the guardianship of the other citizens, and you admit that both within the city and when they go forth to war they ought to keep guard together and hunt together as it were like hounds..." [Plato, The Republic 466c]
Showing posts with label Socrates. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Socrates. Show all posts
Wednesday, January 23, 2013
Sunday, September 2, 2012
Socrates on the 2012 Presidential Election
Prof. Gary Gutting went down to the Piraeus to talk to Socrates about the presidential election coming up in November...
From NYT's The Stone, featuring the writing of contemporary philosophers "on issues both timely and timeless."
SOCRATES: I’m against it.
GUTTING: I see what you mean. It’s going to be nasty, brutish, and long — not to say immensely expensive — but of course if we want a democracy, there’s no alternative.
S: I disagree. You shouldn’t hold the election at all. You should flip a coin instead.
G: You don’t see any difference between Obama and Romney?
S: Oh, I do. I’m very impressed with Obama, no question. He’s intelligent, courageous, self-controlled and has a good sense of justice. Just the sort of person I had in mind for my philosopher-rulers. But none of that’s going to make a difference to the American voters. The election’s likely to be close, and in any case the outcome will turn on the October unemployment report, the price of gas, an Israeli attack on Iran, who has the most money for attack ads in the last two weeks or some other rationally irrelevant factor that you don’t yet have any hint about.
G: But surely you’d prefer to let Obama make his case to the American people rather than let blind chance decide the outcome?
S: I think letting the American people decide is no different from leaving it to chance. The vast majority of you don’t know enough about the issues or the candidates to make anything like a reliable decision. (It was the same in Athens in my day.) Take the economic issues all your commentators say will be decisive. I think Paul Krugman makes a decisive case that, for all its flaws, Obama’s approach to the economy is likely to be far more effective than anything Romney and Ryan have in mind. But there are prominent economists who reject Krugman’s argument. If Krugman’s right, you can’t trust the experts who disagree with him. So why should you trust the judgment of the non-experts whose votes will decide the election?
G: Well, aren’t we voters at least pretty good judges of character and competence?
S: I see nothing in the history of your elections to suggest anything of the sort. Is there any reason to think that over, say, the last 50 years, you’ve elected the “better man” at least half the time?
G: You may be right about this or any other particular election. But it would be crazy to give up the general idea of having elections. At a minimum, the people can tell if a government is grossly incompetent, deeply corrupt or even imposing tyranny. The fact that we have elections that can “throw the rascals out” is our only defense against the worst sorts of government.
S: You may have a point there. I always said tyranny is the one form of government worse than democracy. Let me modify my proposal. Once the parties have chosen their candidates — maybe through some tobacco-free version of the old smoke-filled room — you should immediately have a national referendum on whether to have an election. If things are appallingly bad, people will vote to have one. Otherwise, I’m sure they’ll choose to save money and aggravation, and flip the coin.
G: I’m not so sure. People are used to elections and, for all their complaining, they like the sense that they’re making big decisions — and they find the presidential horse race entertaining.
S: Well, of course, I realize that what I’m proposing goes against present inclinations and prejudices, and it might take some time for people to learn that elections aren’t usually worth the trouble. As you know, I’ve always had a utopian streak. But, details of implementation aside, the point is that what I’m proposing illustrates the only real value of democracy. It’s the best way to avoid tyranny, but it’s not a good way (no better than chance) of choosing policies and leaders. We Greeks, you know, did all right choosing leaders by lot.
G: But don’t presidential elections serve other purposes? Even if we could get just as good leaders and policies from a coin flip, doesn’t the extended discussion and debate of an election produce better formulations of the issues and of the opposing policies for dealing with them?
S: Just the opposite. Under your system, public policy debates are almost entirely political in the worst sense. Politicians are concerned only with making cheap rhetorical points that will arouse popular passions (remember “socialism” and “death panels” from the health care debate). Once you remove the need to gear policies to popular ignorance and fears, politicians will have to propose policies that they can successfully defend in debates among themselves.
G: So you trust the politicians more than you trust the people?
S: Yes, I do. For all their failings, most politicians are reasonably sincere, honest, and much more intelligent and educated on the issues than their constituents. Very few of them come up to the standards I set, but once freed from the necessity of courting uninformed public opinion, most of them could do a creditable job of making decisions in the public interest. And remember, without elections, politicians would no longer need the vast amount of money that gives big donors so much influence.
G: O.K., maybe you’re on to something. But — who’s going to flip the coin?
S: Hmm, I hadn’t thought about that. I suppose the Chief Justice of the United States.
G: Ah ha! There’s the fatal flaw!
From NYT's The Stone, featuring the writing of contemporary philosophers "on issues both timely and timeless."
Friday, January 21, 2011
Allegory of the Cave Assignment
PHL 310 – Ethics
Assignment 3 – Draw Plato’s Cave [25 pts]
Due: Lesson 8 (25 Jan 11)
ASSIGNMENT: You will invariably run across people in your career, both up and down the chain, who just don’t get it. They need a picture.
From your reading assignment, take the description of the cave [514a – 521a] and, on one 8 ½” x 11” piece of printer/copier paper, draw it. Socrates describes several important features of the cave. Make sure you get them all.
Remember, your task is to simplify a complicated image for someone who isn’t getting it. Use labels if you need to (i.e., if your stick people might be mistaken for fish in trees), but don’t write paragraphs.
GRADING: This assignment will be graded on your ability to distill basic facts from the source, determining what is pertinent to get the message across, and to represent the major features in Socrates’ description (15 pts). Neatness and overall artistic ability will also be evaluated, insofar as they contribute to the clarity/communication of your rendition (10 pts).
NOTE: If your work is not only complete, but also aesthetically pleasing and suitable for display, I’ll offer 5 pts extra credit in return for the piece. You’ll know you’re eligible if you see “+5” next to your grade.
Assignment 3 – Draw Plato’s Cave [25 pts]
Due: Lesson 8 (25 Jan 11)
ASSIGNMENT: You will invariably run across people in your career, both up and down the chain, who just don’t get it. They need a picture.
From your reading assignment, take the description of the cave [514a – 521a] and, on one 8 ½” x 11” piece of printer/copier paper, draw it. Socrates describes several important features of the cave. Make sure you get them all.
Remember, your task is to simplify a complicated image for someone who isn’t getting it. Use labels if you need to (i.e., if your stick people might be mistaken for fish in trees), but don’t write paragraphs.
GRADING: This assignment will be graded on your ability to distill basic facts from the source, determining what is pertinent to get the message across, and to represent the major features in Socrates’ description (15 pts). Neatness and overall artistic ability will also be evaluated, insofar as they contribute to the clarity/communication of your rendition (10 pts).
NOTE: If your work is not only complete, but also aesthetically pleasing and suitable for display, I’ll offer 5 pts extra credit in return for the piece. You’ll know you’re eligible if you see “+5” next to your grade.
Wednesday, September 15, 2010
Recap – Lessons 7-9
Socrates’ turn to ethical questions on how one should live a good life was characterized by (1) the subjects of his inquiry, for example, in The Republic, the question what is justice?; and (2) the technique he employed – dialectic – which provided an example of how one should authentically seek knowledge. Compared to the technique employed by the sophists, which was to “win” an argument without particular regard for the truth, dialectic was both more collaborative and more open-ended. It could also be more frustrating, as the discussions rendered by Plato didn’t always yield a definitive conclusion, and we’re often left to develop our own answers.
That was the case after our first reading from The Republic. Your answers to the question, what is justice?, clustered around the notions of it being external and based on punishment and reward. As we read, Socrates dealt with similar formulations from Cephalus, Polemarchus, Thrasymachus, and Glaucon. Each fell short of providing a satisfactory conception. Glaucon proposed perhaps the greatest challenge to any conception of justice by retelling the story of Gyges Ring: what would you do if you could get away with anything?
To answer, Socrates and his companions undertake an elaborate thought experiment where they build a city from scratch, the goal being to first identify where justice resides in the city, then to find analogues in the individual. Our second reading from The Republic described the virtues – wisdom, courage, and moderation – as they appear in both the city and the soul. Justice, it’s finally agreed, is harmony among these virtues, with each performing its function to sustain that balance.
Since justice is internal and not purely motivated by reward and punishment, Socrates and Plato have to take up the final task of answering why one should be just. By way of explaining, Socrates relates the allegory of the cave, which you skillfully rendered for your third assignment. As a metaphor for Plato’s theory of knowledge (the divided line), the story relays the struggle entailed for humans to break free from the comforts of illusion. There’s also a caution: sharing newly acquired wisdom may be hazardous to your health. The allegory also contains a mystery, which some of you identified: who freed the prisoner, and what was his/her status?
That was the case after our first reading from The Republic. Your answers to the question, what is justice?, clustered around the notions of it being external and based on punishment and reward. As we read, Socrates dealt with similar formulations from Cephalus, Polemarchus, Thrasymachus, and Glaucon. Each fell short of providing a satisfactory conception. Glaucon proposed perhaps the greatest challenge to any conception of justice by retelling the story of Gyges Ring: what would you do if you could get away with anything?
To answer, Socrates and his companions undertake an elaborate thought experiment where they build a city from scratch, the goal being to first identify where justice resides in the city, then to find analogues in the individual. Our second reading from The Republic described the virtues – wisdom, courage, and moderation – as they appear in both the city and the soul. Justice, it’s finally agreed, is harmony among these virtues, with each performing its function to sustain that balance.
Since justice is internal and not purely motivated by reward and punishment, Socrates and Plato have to take up the final task of answering why one should be just. By way of explaining, Socrates relates the allegory of the cave, which you skillfully rendered for your third assignment. As a metaphor for Plato’s theory of knowledge (the divided line), the story relays the struggle entailed for humans to break free from the comforts of illusion. There’s also a caution: sharing newly acquired wisdom may be hazardous to your health. The allegory also contains a mystery, which some of you identified: who freed the prisoner, and what was his/her status?
Wednesday, September 8, 2010
Recap – Lessons 5-6
We looked at the arguments made to justify the invasion of Iraq with an eye toward whether or not they were good, i.e., persuasive. That led to a discussion about what happens when a military officer disagrees with the stated policy of our civilian leadership and the decisions of our Commander-in-Chief. Pretty clear consensus that once those decisions are enacted in the form of directives from senior military leadership, we either follow orders or resign. Then we took it a step further: what about those officers who stay and obey yet still disagree? Do they get to state their opinion – privately – to family, friends, or subordinates? Mixed feelings on this, with many of you thinking we should suppress our opinions and toe the line, period-dot. Others observed we can’t help but form opinions, and suppressing them when someone asks would be tantamount to BS. In both cases, the effect on the morale of our subordinates was the primary motivator: toe the line so as not to discourage our Airmen, vs. be honest, because our Airmen will recognize BS.
Following Martin Cook’s comparison of two superpowers – the United States after the Cold War and ancient Athens after the Persian Wars – we explored some analogues between the Peloponnesian War and OIF. We looked at the difference between preemptive and preventive justifications for going to war (jus ad bellum), at the types of coalitions each conflict spawned, and at the harsh realism of the Athenians vs. the false dilemma embedded in our own policy, both of which resulted in a “with us or against us” stance toward other nations.
We also talked about the effects of war. For Athens, the Peloponnesian War ushered in the end of her domination of the Greeks, the “brief, shining moment” that marked the beginning of Western culture. The effect of OIF on the U.S. is still unwritten. As Secretary Gates recently told reporters, “the problem with this war for, I think, many Americans is that the premise on which we justified going to war proved not to be valid — that is, Saddam having weapons of mass destruction.” He added, candidly: “It will always be clouded by how it began.”
History will clarify what good comes out of OIF. From the Peloponnesian War, one positive outcome we identified was the re-focusing of philosophy into ethical realms of inquiry. Philosophy had already existed in an early form prior to the war. Its path out of the ancient Greek religion, what we now call mythology, appears when the earliest philosophers, the pre-Socratics, sought naturalistic explanations for life’s everyday challenges. They formed explanations based on their observations of nature, as opposed to relying on the presence of gods and the gods’ interaction with humanity to explain how and why the world worked. Even then, the pre-Socratics couldn’t wholly escape the religious context of their time, and many of their explanations retained mythic qualities. It wasn’t until Socrates developed his style of street philosophy that the ancient, mythopoeic ethic (based on punishment and reward) would begin to be challenged.
Following Martin Cook’s comparison of two superpowers – the United States after the Cold War and ancient Athens after the Persian Wars – we explored some analogues between the Peloponnesian War and OIF. We looked at the difference between preemptive and preventive justifications for going to war (jus ad bellum), at the types of coalitions each conflict spawned, and at the harsh realism of the Athenians vs. the false dilemma embedded in our own policy, both of which resulted in a “with us or against us” stance toward other nations.
We also talked about the effects of war. For Athens, the Peloponnesian War ushered in the end of her domination of the Greeks, the “brief, shining moment” that marked the beginning of Western culture. The effect of OIF on the U.S. is still unwritten. As Secretary Gates recently told reporters, “the problem with this war for, I think, many Americans is that the premise on which we justified going to war proved not to be valid — that is, Saddam having weapons of mass destruction.” He added, candidly: “It will always be clouded by how it began.”
History will clarify what good comes out of OIF. From the Peloponnesian War, one positive outcome we identified was the re-focusing of philosophy into ethical realms of inquiry. Philosophy had already existed in an early form prior to the war. Its path out of the ancient Greek religion, what we now call mythology, appears when the earliest philosophers, the pre-Socratics, sought naturalistic explanations for life’s everyday challenges. They formed explanations based on their observations of nature, as opposed to relying on the presence of gods and the gods’ interaction with humanity to explain how and why the world worked. Even then, the pre-Socratics couldn’t wholly escape the religious context of their time, and many of their explanations retained mythic qualities. It wasn’t until Socrates developed his style of street philosophy that the ancient, mythopoeic ethic (based on punishment and reward) would begin to be challenged.
Labels:
JAB,
myth,
OIF,
Peloponnesian War,
pre-Socratics,
realism,
Socrates
Wednesday, September 1, 2010
Quotes from The Republic
The safest general characterization of the European philosophical tradition is that it consists of a series of footnotes to Plato. - Alfred North Whitehead
Before we leave Socrates and Plato, if we ever really do, I thought I’d share some of my favorite quotes from The Republic...
[352d] …the argument is not about just any question, but about the way one should live.
[334b] “No, by Zeus,” (Polemarchus) said. “But I no longer know what I did mean.”
[363d] …the finest wage of virtue is an eternal drunk.
[350e] “…if you want to keep on questioning, go ahead and question, and, just as with old wives who tell tales, I shall say to you, ‘All right,’ and I shall nod and shake my head.”
[387d] …the decent man will believe that for the decent man—who happens to be his comrade—being dead is not a terrible thing.
[403a] “It’s ridiculous,” (Glaucon) said, “if the Guardian needs a Guardian.”
[457a] The women guardians must strip, since they’ll clothe themselves in virtue instead of robes, and they must take common part in war …
[459d.] There is a need for the best men to have intercourse as often as possible with the best women.
[338d] “You are disgusting, Socrates.”
[474a] “Socrates, what a phrase and argument you have let burst out. Now that it’s said, you can believe that very many men, and not ordinary ones, will on the spot throw off their clothes, and stripped for action, taking hold of whatever weapon falls under the hand of each, run full speed at you and do wonderful deeds.”
Before we leave Socrates and Plato, if we ever really do, I thought I’d share some of my favorite quotes from The Republic...
[352d] …the argument is not about just any question, but about the way one should live.
[334b] “No, by Zeus,” (Polemarchus) said. “But I no longer know what I did mean.”
[363d] …the finest wage of virtue is an eternal drunk.
[350e] “…if you want to keep on questioning, go ahead and question, and, just as with old wives who tell tales, I shall say to you, ‘All right,’ and I shall nod and shake my head.”
[387d] …the decent man will believe that for the decent man—who happens to be his comrade—being dead is not a terrible thing.
[403a] “It’s ridiculous,” (Glaucon) said, “if the Guardian needs a Guardian.”
[457a] The women guardians must strip, since they’ll clothe themselves in virtue instead of robes, and they must take common part in war …
[459d.] There is a need for the best men to have intercourse as often as possible with the best women.
[338d] “You are disgusting, Socrates.”
[474a] “Socrates, what a phrase and argument you have let burst out. Now that it’s said, you can believe that very many men, and not ordinary ones, will on the spot throw off their clothes, and stripped for action, taking hold of whatever weapon falls under the hand of each, run full speed at you and do wonderful deeds.”
Thursday, August 26, 2010
The Republic - Reading Guide II
How to use the reading guide:
The second reading from The Republic is broken down into sections of argument (using the Stephanus pagination). Identify the main points of each section and follow the flow of the overall dialogue as the participants move from one argument to the next.

The second reading from The Republic is broken down into sections of argument (using the Stephanus pagination). Identify the main points of each section and follow the flow of the overall dialogue as the participants move from one argument to the next.

Labels:
Plato,
reading guide,
Socrates,
The Republic,
virtues
Tuesday, August 24, 2010
What is Justice?
Here are the results from the discussions last class on how you would define justice:
Justice is...
So for the most part, justice is something external that is done to you, and it’s evenhanded.
When we talked about the Ancient Greek religion (what we refer to now as the Greek myths), we talked about how the myths coalesced into a shared heritage of ancestral memories relayed down generations and later, how they formed patterns of belief that gave meaning to life and formed the basis of moral codes.
One of those patterns might be reflected in your conception of justice, the mythopoeic ethic. In Greek mythology, the “moral of the story” often revolved around punishment and reward: please the gods and be rewarded; oppose the gods and standby for punishment.
Perhaps there’s some resonance between your conception of justice and your life here at the Academy. We’ll see what Socrates has to say about that…
Justice is...
1st Period – getting what one deserves in terms of punishment and reward; karma
2nd Period – the fair, balanced and reasonable distribution of “stuff”
3rd Period – the fair dispersal of rewards and punishment
4th Period – the perception of what’s due; the permissibility of making honest mistakes
So for the most part, justice is something external that is done to you, and it’s evenhanded.
When we talked about the Ancient Greek religion (what we refer to now as the Greek myths), we talked about how the myths coalesced into a shared heritage of ancestral memories relayed down generations and later, how they formed patterns of belief that gave meaning to life and formed the basis of moral codes.
One of those patterns might be reflected in your conception of justice, the mythopoeic ethic. In Greek mythology, the “moral of the story” often revolved around punishment and reward: please the gods and be rewarded; oppose the gods and standby for punishment.
Perhaps there’s some resonance between your conception of justice and your life here at the Academy. We’ll see what Socrates has to say about that…
Friday, August 20, 2010
The Republic - Reading Guide I
How to use the reading guide:
The first reading from The Republic is broken down into sections of argument (using the Stephanus pagination). Identify the main points of each section and follow the flow of the overall dialogue as the participants move from one argument to the next.

The first reading from The Republic is broken down into sections of argument (using the Stephanus pagination). Identify the main points of each section and follow the flow of the overall dialogue as the participants move from one argument to the next.

Labels:
Justice,
Plato,
reading guide,
Socrates,
The Republic
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)